[Discussion] Shark tooth vs Magnus Gear

I've been wondering, which gears would be better out of the scenarios:

Scenario 1 [Tyrant shoe, and cape not used, Cygnus shoulder used]
-7 Set Full cygnus equipments:
Why this is good: 55wa, 30% boss and 30% hp/mp
-Tyrant belt

Scenario 2 [Tyrant shoe or cape not used, Cygnus shoulder used]
-6 Set Full cygnus equipments:
Why this is good: 40 wa, 30% boss and 15% hp/mp
-Tyrant belt
-Tyrant cape/shoe

Scenario 3 [All 3 tyrant equipments used, Cygnus shoulder used]
-5 set Full cygnus equipments
Only bonus left: 15wa, 15% hp/mp

Scenario 4 [All 3 tyrant equipments used, applicable to warriors and thieves only]
-NONE of the cygnus equipments used
-3 tyrant equipments used.
-Top and bottom gives more % stat.

I honestly feel scenario 4 would give the best overall damage boost because tyrant equipments gives a crazy amount of stat boost. However, I also think that only emitting 1 part of the tyrant equipment and giving 30% more boss damage actually might be able to overcome scenario 4. Which scenario do you guys think is the best equipment configuration?